Momentum ETFs offer low-cost, rules-based exposure to momentum investing, while active momentum PMS strategies aim to enhance returns using filters like quality and earnings. However, after fees and taxes, ETFs often outperform unless the PMS manager generates significant alpha.
The debate between momentum ETF vs active momentum PMS India comes down to one key question: can active managers consistently beat a rules-based strategy after costs and taxes? While both approaches follow momentum investing, their execution and outcomes differ significantly.
Active momentum strategies attempt to reduce drawdowns, but higher costs create a significant hurdle to outperform ETFs on a net basis.
Global data suggests ~65–70% of active managers underperform benchmarks over 5 years (Source: SPIVA India reports).
Low cost ensures minimal drag on long-term returns.
Higher cost structure significantly reduces net returns.
| Component | Momentum ETF | Active PMS |
|---|---|---|
| Expense Ratio | 0.20–0.30% | 1–2.5% |
| Performance Fee | None | 10–20% |
| Total Cost Impact | Low | High |
At a 30% tax slab, higher turnover in PMS can reduce returns by 5–8% annually compared to ETFs.
| Investor Type | Best Option |
|---|---|
| Retail investors | Momentum ETF |
| HNI investors (>₹50L) | Momentum PMS |
| Cost-sensitive investors | ETF |
| Alpha-seeking investors | PMS |
Explore Portfolio Management Services (PMS) for active strategies, open a Demat account to invest in ETFs, and use the ReSach App to track momentum trends in real time.
Compare Momentum ETF vs PMS Now
Monarch Networth Capital Limited (MNCL) is a SEBI-registered Portfolio Manager (Registration No. INP000006059). Investments in securities market are subject to market risks. This content is for educational purposes only. Read full disclaimer.
Empower your finances with ReSach – the stock trading apptrusted by serious investors. Whether you're planning to invest in stocks, explore commodity trading, or need a financial advisor to guide you, Resach brings it all under one platform.
Start trading today with ReSach and unlock seamless investing on the go.
Name of the Company has changed from Networth Stock Broking Limited to Monarch Networth Capital Limited upon Certification of Incorporation received from Registrar of Companies, Mumbai vide certificate dated 13th October, 2015.
If you are not satisfied with the resolution provided, you can lodge your complaint online at: https://scores.sebi.gov.in/link
In case of grievance client can log on to the SMART ODR Portal, if they are unsatisfied with the response provided by us. Your attention is drawn to the SEBI circular no. SEBI/HO/OIAE/OIAE_IAD-1/P/CIR/2023/131 dated July 31, 2023, on “Online Resolution of Disputes in the Indian Securities Market”.
Purchase of REs only gives buyer the right to participate in the ongoing Rights Issue of the concerned company by making an application with requisite application money or renounce the REs before the issue closes. REs which are neither subscribed by making an application with requisite application money nor renounced, on or before the Issue closing date shall lapse and shall be extinguished after the Issue closing date. Please check your dp account for further details.
Please do not share your online trading password with anyone as this could weaken the security of your account and lead to unauthorized trades or losses.
Monarch Networth Capital Limited (‘MNCL’) | CIN No.: L64990GJ1993PLC120014
Unit No. 803-804A, 8th Floor, X-Change Plaza, Block No. 53, Zone 5, Road-5E, Gift City, Gandhinagar - 382050, Gujarat
Ahmedabad
“Monarch House”, Opp Prahladbhai Patel garden, Near Ishwar Bhuvan, Commerce Six Roads, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad - 380009
Mumbai
Monarch Networth Capital Limited, G Block, Laxmi Tower, B Wing, 4th Floor, Bandra Kurla Complex, Bandra East, Mumbai - 400051.
Email for Grievance: grievances@mnclgroup.com
Investors are requested to note that Stock broker (Monarch Networth Capital Ltd) is permitted to receive money from investors through designated bank accounts only named as Up streaming Client Nodal Bank Account (USCNBA). Stock broker (Monarch Networth Capital Ltd) is also required to disclose these USCNB accounts to Stock Exchange. Hence, you are requested to use following USCNB accounts only (Click to View) for the purpose of dealings in your trading account with us. The details of these USCNB accounts are also displayed by Stock Exchanges on their website under “Know/ Locate your Stock Broker".
Mechanism for addressing grievances and information about SCORES.
Monarch Networth Capital IFSC Private Limited (Wholly owned subsidiary of Monarch Networth Capital Limited) is a Registered Fund Management Entity (Retail) having Registration No: IFSCA/FME/III/2025-26/169. Monarch India Growth Fund will be an open-ended Restricted Scheme (Non-Retail) construed as a Category III AIF under the IFSCA (Fund Management) Regulations, 2025. Monarch AIF is a Category III AIF having SEBI Registration No. IN/AIF3/20-21/0787. This material is for informational purposes only and is not intended as an offer or solicitation or investment advice to buy or sell securities. Investments are subject to market risks. The offering is made only through official scheme documents to eligible investors under GIFT IFSC regulations. Investors should read all documents carefully and consult their advisors before investing.
Mechanism for addressing grievances and information about SCORES.
Monarch Networth Capital Limited (‘MNCL’) | CIN No.: L64990GJ1993PLC120014
(As per LODR Regulations and Companies Act, 2013)
Contact information of the designated officials of the listed entity who are responsible for assisting and handling investor grievances : Mr. Nitesh Tanwar : 022 - 66476400 / 66476405
Monarch Networth Capital Limited
Unit No. 803-804A, 8th Floor, X-Change Plaza, Block No. 53, Zone 5, Road-5E, Gift City, Gandhinagar - 382050, Gujarat
Ahmedabad
“Monarch House”, Opp Prahladbhai Patel garden, Near Ishwar Bhuvan, Commerce Six Roads, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad – 380009
Mumbai
Monarch Networth Capital Limited, G Block, Laxmi Tower, B Wing, 4th Floor, Bandra Kurla Complex, Bandra East, Mumbai - 400051.
For Broking and Demat Related Queries : +91-79-26666768
Email: cs@mnclgroup.com
Email for Grievance: cs@mnclgroup.com
Listing of Equity Shares on Stock Exchange at
BSE
NSE
(Formerly known as Link Intime India Private Limited)
For any queries related to broking please contact helpdesk@mnclgroup.com.
‘Investments in securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing.’
